In a work culture that often prioritizes relentless optimism, the well-intentioned pursuit of positivity can sometimes go too far. Leaders who dismiss genuine concerns with phrases like "I need you to stay positive" or "Take it easy" or "Good vibes only!" may inadvertently be contributing to the phenomenon known as toxic positivity. While promoting a positive outlook is beneficial, it's crucial for leaders to understand the science behind how forced optimism can backfire, impacting both individual well-being and overall team performance.
The Neuroscience of Toxic Positivity
Our brains are complex, and our emotional responses are influenced by intricate neural activity. When a colleague expresses frustration or a team member voices a concern, the amygdala – a key brain region involved in emotional processing – is activated. Attempts to suppress these emotions with toxic positivity don't make them magically disappear. Instead, this creates additional cognitive load for everyone involved, hindering rational thinking and problem-solving.
Furthermore, the concept of mirror neurons plays a significant role. These specialized brain cells allow us to empathize with others, mirroring their emotions. When a leader dismisses or minimizes an employee's negative feelings, it sends a signal that those feelings are invalid. This can lead to disconnection and isolation, further compounding the individual's distress.
The Social Cost and the Leader's Role
The fallout from toxic positivity extends beyond individual brain function. When genuine emotions are constantly stifled, it erodes the foundation of authentic connection within a team. Over time, individuals may feel hesitant to share their honest experiences due to a fear of being dismissed or judged. This lack of genuine connection breeds loneliness and undermines team cohesion.
Pervasive toxic positivity also aligns with cultural conditioning into how we expect others to operate in the workplace. By continuously/perpetually front-loading positivity — regardless of circumstance/emotional experience — we inadvertently sabotage emotional growth and resilience for our teams.
So, what’s a leader to do? The answer lies in understanding your role as an emotional regulator for your team and creating the space for those you lead to have access to a full range of emotional experiences.
Effective Emotional Regulation in Leadership
The role that leaders play in setting the emotional tone for their teams is pivotal. Here’s how to break free of toxic positivity cycles for leaders with concrete examples and a spotlight on the PERMA model:
Positive Psychology and the PERMA Model: Positive psychology specifically applied to setting the emotional tone of a team. The PERMA model (developed by Dr. Martin Seligman) identifies five key elements that contribute to well-being: Positive Emotions (P), Engagement (E), Relationships (R), Meaning (M), and Accomplishment (A).
Instead of…“You’re just being negative. Just focus on the good in the situation!”
say this… “It sounds like you’re feeling a bit of frustration from the situation. Can you say more about what’s causing you some concern?”
PERMA Connection: Open communication and expressing to your team member that you recognize that they are feeling something that is reasonable based on the circumstances (Relationships).
Instead of…“It’s really not that bad. You shouldn’t worry about it. Other people have it much worse than you do.”
say this… “It seems like this is really causing you to internalize a lot of stress. What’s one thing that I can do to be a resource to you and help you better manage this moving forward?”
PERMA Connection:Transitioning from the emotional experience to a conversation about solutions that they would like to see come to the surface. Offers a sense of control and self-generated plan going forward (Accomplishment, Engagement).
Instead of... "Let's just move on, we don't have time to dwell on this."
say this... "I appreciate you raising this issue. Can we schedule a bit of time later to discuss it properly?"
PERMA Connection: Acknowledges the importance of the issue (Meaning) and demonstrates your commitment to addressing it (Engagement).
Balance is Key
This doesn't mean there's no place for positivity in the workplace. The trick is to strike a balance between fostering optimism and allowing for authentic emotional expression. Leaders can encourage team members to develop emotional awareness and healthy coping mechanisms, and model vulnerability by being transparent about their own challenges and struggles.
Take our free short quiz to assess the level of emotional authenticity in your team.
Conclusion
By understanding the neurological and social impacts of toxic positivity, and applying principles of positive psychology like the PERMA model, leaders can create more inclusive and emotionally supportive work environments. Fostering a culture where a full range of emotions are respected and acknowledged leads to stronger team relationships, effective problem-solving, and ultimately, a more successful and resilient organization.
To take our free short quiz to assess the level of authenticity in your team:
630.699.5281
Comments